Report date: 2026-11-03
Analysis focus
Provide a balanced, comprehensive analysis: fundamentals and valuation, the Wall Street view, technical posture, and the key forward risks and catalysts.
Summary
Findings (25)
Q3 2026 free cash flow was $816 million, a 22% FCF margin, with trailing-twelve-month FCF of roughly $2.7 billion (19% margin); the balance sheet carries $4,727 million of cash and marketable securities ($1,868M cash + $2,859M securities) against only $188 million of total debt, a net cash position of about $4.5 billion.
High confidenceThe press release reports $816M FCF at a 22% margin and the cash/securities split; aggregator data shows total debt of $188M and net cash of $4.54B, and the Q3 slide coverage cites TTM FCF of $2.7B at a 19% margin.
SHOP closed at $142.57 on November 3, 2026, down 8.74% on the day, after gapping down from the prior close of $156.22 to open at $136.43 following Q3 2026 results.
High confidenceStockAnalysis lists the Nov 3, 2026 close at $142.57 (-8.74%); MarketBeat documents the pre-market gap down from a $156.22 prior close to a $136.43 open, and Globe and Mail reported an intraday decline as steep as 15.1%, so the headline 'down 15%' figures circulating refer to intraday lows rather than the official close.
Q4 2026 guidance was effectively in line to slightly soft — revenue growth at a 'low-thirties' percentage rate versus 32.1% consensus, gross profit dollars growing at a high-twenties rate, operating expenses of 29%-30% of revenue, stock-based compensation of $155 million, and a free cash flow margin consistent with Q4 2025.
High confidenceShopify's Q3 2026 release states each guidance element verbatim; CNBC frames the 'low thirties' revenue outlook against 32.1% LSEG consensus, and Investing.com's coverage of the earnings deck attributes part of the share decline to the spending/investment outlook rather than to the reported quarter.
Shopify reported Q3 2026 (quarter ended Sept 30, 2026) revenue of $3,742 million, up 32% year over year (32% in constant currency), with GMV of $119,145 million, up 29.5%.
High confidenceThe Q3 2026 earnings press release filed as Exhibit 99.1 to Shopify's Form 8-K states revenue of $3,742 million and 32% growth, and GMV of $119,145 million; the company's own newsroom release repeats the 32% revenue growth headline.
Q3 2026 GAAP diluted EPS was $0.36 on net income of $462 million, while non-GAAP diluted EPS was $0.49 (vs. $0.34 a year earlier) and beat the ~$0.47 consensus — the GAAP/non-GAAP gap is driven by one-time items, chiefly $122 million of after-tax net losses on equity and other investments (net loss of $117 million pre-tax) partly offset by a $68 million deferred tax recovery.
High confidenceThe 8-K press release itemizes GAAP net income $462M / diluted EPS $0.36, non-GAAP net income $638M / EPS $0.49, the $117M net investment loss ($122M after tax) and the $68M deferred tax recovery; secondary coverage confirms the $0.49 figure topped the $0.47 estimate. Excluding the mark-to-market investment swing, the underlying operating result — GAAP operating income of $568 million — is the cleaner comparison.
Shopify pays no dividend (dividend yield N/A, no declared or changed dividend), returning capital only via modest buybacks at roughly a 0.90% buyback yield.
High confidenceBoth aggregator pages show no dividend for SHOP and list a buyback yield of 0.90%; no dividend initiation, raise, or cut appears in the Q3 2026 release.
On these prices SHOP carries a trailing P/E of roughly 87x, forward P/E of roughly 64x, P/B of ~15.8x, EV/Sales of ~12.8x and EV/EBITDA in the 70x–95x range, against TTM revenue of $14.17 billion (+32.5%) and TTM net income of $2.13 billion.
Medium confidenceAggregator statistics give trailing P/E 87.35, forward P/E 64.33, P/B 15.76, EV/Sales 12.80 and EV/EBITDA 69.70, plus TTM revenue/net income; independent screens put EV/EBITDA at 95.63 and 83.85 on slightly different dates and EBITDA definitions, which is why the multiple is given as a range rather than a single number.
Current multiples sit well above Shopify's own recent history — EV/EBITDA near 70x–96x versus a ~50x five-year average, and P/S of ~15–16x versus a 12.1x–19.7x band over the past several quarters — and far above its nearest large commerce peer Amazon at ~20x trailing / ~25x forward earnings, 4.3x book, 15.5x EV/EBITDA and 3.6x EV/Sales.
Medium confidenceThe EV/EBITDA history page gives a 5-year average of 49.92 against a current 95.63, and GuruFocus shows 83.85 versus a 9.96 software-industry median; Amazon's statistics page supplies the peer multiples. The comparison is directional — Shopify's 32% revenue growth and 22% FCF margin are structurally different from Amazon's scale and currently negative FCF (-$46.9B TTM on $215.2B capex), so the premium is not like-for-like.
Revenue mix is skewing toward lower-margin merchant solutions: subscription solutions revenue grew only 20% to $836 million and MRR rose 19% to $230 million, while merchant solutions revenue grew 35% to $2,906 million — and gross profit grew 28%, slower than the 32% revenue growth.
High confidenceThe primary 8-K press release gives the segment revenue, MRR and gross profit growth figures; gross profit of $1,781 million growing 28% against 32% revenue growth quantifies the mix-driven gross margin compression. Secondary commentary identifies the 20% subscription growth as the specific line that missed Street forecasts.
Q4 2026 guidance calls for revenue growth at a 'low-thirties' percentage rate but gross profit dollar growth only at a 'high-twenties' rate, with operating expenses at 29–30% of revenue, stock-based compensation of $155 million, and an FCF margin consistent with Q4 2025 — i.e. no guided margin expansion despite ~30% top-line growth.
High confidenceThe guidance ranges are stated verbatim in the Q3 2026 press release; Investing.com's read of the Q3 slide deck frames the flat guided FCF margin and AI/go-to-market spending as the reason shares sold off.
Wall Street consensus is Buy/Strong Buy with an average 12-month price target clustering between $176 and $178 across trackers (stockanalysis.com $176.44 from its analyst set; MarketBeat $177.79 from 49 analysts; Benzinga $176.88 from 54 analysts), a target range of $130 to $216, and a Strong Buy tally of 29 Buys versus 3 Holds among 32 analysts in the trailing three months — implying roughly 24% upside from the $142.69 close.
Medium confidenceThree independent aggregators report averages within $1.35 of one another and the same $130–$216 bounds, which cross-validates the level; the 29 Buy / 3 Hold breakdown comes from TipRanks' trailing-three-month panel. Confidence is medium because all four are secondary aggregators with differing analyst counts and lag windows, and most targets predate the Nov 3 print.
The stock sits about 6.7% below its 50-day moving average of $152.77 but roughly 9.8% above its 200-day moving average of $129.81, so the longer-term golden-cross structure (50-day above 200-day) survived the earnings break even as the short-term trend broke down.
High confidenceStockAnalysis gives a 50-day MA of $152.77 and 200-day MA of $129.81; MarketBeat independently cites $152.91 and $130.21, and both place the 50-day well above the 200-day. Percentage gaps are computed from the $142.57 close.
The decline was driven by growth-metric misses rather than profitability: Q3 2026 revenue of $3.742 billion (+32% y/y, also +32% constant currency) came in just under the $3.75 billion LSEG consensus, GMV of $119.15 billion (+29.5%) missed the $120.03 billion estimate, and subscription solutions revenue of $836 million missed $848.1 million, while adjusted EPS of $0.49 beat the $0.46 estimate.
High confidenceCNBC lists each actual versus LSEG estimate line by line, and Shopify's own press release confirms 32% revenue growth, $119 billion GMV and a 22% free cash flow margin. Neither the company release nor CNBC's coverage identifies any one-time item (tariff refund, asset sale, insurance or legal settlement) inside the EPS beat, so the beat appears operational, driven by margin rather than by a non-recurring gain.
SHOP trades at about $142.69 (down 8.7% on the Nov 3, 2026 earnings session, after a $156.22 close on Nov 2) for a market cap near $183.6 billion and enterprise value near $179.1 billion, versus a 52-week range of $94.00–$180.88.
Medium confidenceAggregator quote pages show the $142.69 intraday print (-8.66%), the $183.58B market cap and $179.05B EV, and the 52-week range; a separate quote source confirms the $156.22 prior close. Confidence is medium because intraday prices and market caps differ across snapshots (other trackers showed $147.88 and caps from $204B to $253B on the same day), so these are point-in-time secondary figures, not filed data.
Shopify's Q3 2026 (quarter ended Sept 30, 2026) revenue was $3,742 million, up 32% year over year, with GMV of $119,145 million (+29%), operating income of $568 million (+66%) and free cash flow of $816 million at a 22% FCF margin versus 18% in Q3 2025.
High confidenceAll figures are taken directly from the Q3 2026 earnings press release filed as Exhibit 99.1 to Shopify's Form 8-K, a primary company filing.
Reported Q3 2026 net income was $462 million, but excluding $122 million of after-tax losses on equity and other investments, net income was $584 million — meaning roughly 26% of the gap between reported and adjusted profit came from a non-operating mark-to-market item rather than core commerce performance.
High confidenceThe 8-K press release states net income of $462 million and $584 million excluding equity investment losses of $122 million net of taxes, and management explicitly labels these gains/losses as outside its control. Any EPS 'beat/miss' framing should normalize for this item, which is volatile and non-recurring in direction.
SHOP fell sharply on the Nov 3, 2026 print, closing at $142.69, down 8.66% on the day, with GMV and subscription revenue each missing consensus by less than 2% and revenue growth landing inside rather than above guidance.
Medium confidencestockanalysis.com shows a $142.69 close, down 8.66%; CNBC and Motley Fool coverage attribute the decline to a GMV/revenue miss versus elevated expectations and heavier spending plans rather than to a deterioration in reported growth. Confidence is medium because intraday decline figures cited across aggregators ranged from roughly -7.6% to -15.3%, so only the closing print should be treated as firm.
Among major banks the dispersion is wide and straddles the current price: Citi raised its target to $216 from $196 (Buy, Oct 28, 2026), Morgan Stanley stands at $192, Wells Fargo at $191, KeyCorp lifted to $185 from $180 (Nov 2, 2026), Goldman Sachs at $168, Barclays at $145 (Hold), while DA Davidson cut to $180 from $200 on valuation — so the low end of major-bank coverage sits roughly at the $142.69 close and the high end about 51% above it.
Medium confidenceBenzinga's price-target table supplies the firm-by-firm levels and action dates; MarketBeat's instant alert documents the KeyCorp raise to $185 dated Nov 2, 2026, and Investing.com documents DA Davidson's cut to $180 on valuation. Confidence is medium: the Goldman ($168, Feb 2026) and Wells Fargo ($191, Feb 2026) marks are stale by roughly nine months and several targets were set before Q3 results, so the effective consensus may reset lower or higher in the days after the print.
Valuation remains demanding in absolute terms but is below its own recent norm and far above a high-growth peer: SHOP trades at 87.4x trailing and 64.3x forward earnings, 13.1x sales and 69.7x EV/EBITDA on a $183.6 billion market cap, versus a reported ~90.8x five-year median trailing P/E, while MercadoLibre trades at 45.3x trailing, 40.3x forward and 2.4x sales.
Medium confidenceThe SHOP and MELI multiples are from stockanalysis.com's statistics pages as of Nov 3, 2026; the ~90.76x five-year median P/E benchmark comes from secondary commentary, which is the weakest link in the claim. The P/S gap (13.1x vs 2.4x) partly reflects business-model differences — Shopify's take-rate-on-GMV model books far less gross revenue per dollar of commerce than MercadoLibre's first-party retail and logistics mix — so the sales multiple is not directly comparable even though the earnings multiples are closer in kind.
Shopify trades at 13.1x trailing and 10.4x forward sales, 87x trailing and 64x forward earnings, and 69.7x EV/EBITDA on a $183.4 billion market cap — a valuation that only holds up against growth, as the closest listed pure-play peer, Commerce.com (formerly BigCommerce, CMRC), trades at 0.79x sales and 8.4x forward earnings on a 3-year revenue growth forecast of just 2.18%.
Medium confidenceStockAnalysis gives SHOP's post-drop multiples (PE 87.28, forward PE 64.33, PS 13.12, forward PS 10.36, EV/EBITDA 69.70, market cap $183.44B) and the peer's (PS 0.79, forward PE 8.37, 3Y revenue growth forecast 2.18%). TipRanks shows higher figures (PE 113.18, forward PE 79.84, PS 16.08) consistent with a pre-selloff price, which is why the multiple set should be read as of a specific close rather than as a single number.
The Wall Street consensus remains constructive — 'Buy'/'Moderate Buy' across 54-55 analysts with an average 12-month target of roughly $176-$178 (about 24% above the $142.57 close), targets spanning about $120 to $220, Citi at $216 and RBC Capital at $200 — against a 5-year beta of 2.66 that implies well above market volatility around upcoming catalysts.
Medium confidenceTipRanks shows a 'Buy' consensus from 54 analysts with a $176.88 average target and cites the Citi $216 and RBC $200 raises; StockAnalysis shows a $176.44 average from 55 analysts and beta (5Y) of 2.66; MarketBeat shows 'Moderate Buy' with a $178.44 average. These targets largely predate the Q3 print, so revisions over the following days are the thing to watch rather than treating the average as current.
Wall Street remains constructive — consensus 'Buy' across 55 analysts with an average target of $176.44, about 24% above the post-earnings price — while the stock's technical posture has deteriorated: it trades below its 50-day moving average of $152.81 but still above its 200-day of $129.82, is down 17% over 52 weeks, and carries a high 5-year beta of 2.66 with only 1.61% short interest.
Medium confidenceThe quote and statistics pages show the 55-analyst Buy consensus and $176.44 average target, the 50-day/200-day moving averages, the -17.0% 52-week change, beta of 2.66 and 20.78M shares short (1.61% of outstanding). These are aggregator snapshots that may not yet reflect post-Q3 target revisions.
Technically the stock closed below its 50-day moving average of $152.77 but still well above its 200-day of $129.81, is down 17.93% over 52 weeks, carries a 5-year beta of 2.66, and has modest short interest of 20.78 million shares (1.61% of shares outstanding).
Medium confidenceMoving averages, 52-week change, beta and short interest are from stockanalysis.com's statistics page dated Nov 3, 2026; pre-earnings technical commentary flagged support in the C$223 area (TSX listing) heading into the print. The 50-day/200-day configuration means the near-term trend has broken while the longer-term uptrend is intact, and a 2.66 beta indicates outsized sensitivity to broad market moves.
SHOP's trailing 12-month return is -18.0%, leaving the stock roughly 21% below its 52-week high of $180.88 and about 52% above its 52-week low of $94.00, with year-to-date gains cut from roughly +35% pre-earnings to roughly +23% after the November 3 drop.
Medium confidenceStockAnalysis reports a 52-week return of -18.00% and a 52-week range of $94.00-$180.88; the distance-from-high/low and the post-drop YTD figure are arithmetic from the cited $142.57 close and the cited pre-earnings 'up 35% year-to-date' reference, so they are derived rather than directly published.
RSI(14) stands at roughly 33-36 and MACD (12,26,9) is negative at -6.92, indicating momentum has deteriorated to the low end of neutral without yet registering a technically oversold reading below 30.
Medium confidenceStockAnalysis lists RSI(14) at 33.26 as of Nov 3, 2026, while a same-day aggregator reading cites RSI 36.00 and MACD -6.922; the spread reflects different intraday snapshots, and both are above the conventional 30 oversold threshold.
Sources (28)
- https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0001594805/000159480526000067/exhibit991pressreleaseq320.htmfundamentalsPrimary
- https://www.shopify.com/news/shopify-q3-2026-financial-resultsfundamentalsPrimary
- https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/shop/fundamentalsSecondary
- https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/shop/statistics/fundamentalsSecondary
- https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/amzn/statistics/fundamentalsSecondary
- https://valueinvesting.io/SHOP/valuation/ev_ebitda-multiplesfundamentalsSecondary
- https://www.gurufocus.com/term/enterprise-value-to-ebitda/SHOPfundamentalsSecondary
- https://www.investing.com/news/company-news/shopify-q3-2026-slides-ai-drives-growth-as-shares-fall-on-spending-93CH-4995898fundamentalsSecondary
- https://www.investing.com/news/transcripts/earnings-call-transcript-shopify-tops-profit-view-in-q3-2026-but-shares-fall-93CH-4995839fundamentalsSecondary
- https://www.heygotrade.com/en/us-stock/shop/fundamentalsSecondary
- https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/03/shopify-q3-2026-earnings-gmv.htmlanalyst_targetsSecondary
- https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/shop/forecast/analyst_targetsSecondary
- https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/meli/statistics/analyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.marketbeat.com/stocks/NASDAQ/SHOP/forecast/analyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.marketbeat.com/instant-alerts/analyst-shopify-nasdaq-shop-stock-price-target-raised-at-keycorp-2026-11-02/analyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.benzinga.com/quote/SHOP/price-targetsanalyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.benzinga.com/quote/SHOP/analyst-ratingsanalyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.tipranks.com/news/shopify-shop-faces-q3-earnings-tomorrow-heres-what-analysts-expectanalyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.investing.com/news/analyst-ratings/da-davidson-cuts-shopify-stock-price-target-on-valuation-concerns-93CH-4996165analyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.fool.com/investing/2026/11/03/why-shopify-stock-dove-today/analyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.scommerce.com/shopify-stock-falls-subscriptions/analyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.scommerce.com/shopify-stock-outlook-q4/analyst_targetsSecondary
- https://www.tradingkey.com/analysis/stocks/us-stocks/262260653-shopify-stock-forecast-q3-earnings-preview-agentic-commerce-c223-support-november-1-2026-tradingkeyanalyst_targetsSecondary
- https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/bigc/statistics/technicalsSecondary
- https://www.marketbeat.com/instant-alerts/price-shopify-nasdaq-shop-shares-gap-down-heres-what-happened-2026-11-03/technicalsSecondary
- https://www.tipranks.com/stocks/shoptechnicalsSecondary
- https://www.theglobeandmail.com/investing/markets/stocks/SHOP/pressreleases/8614682/shopifys-nasdaqshop-q3-2026-earnings-results-revenue-in-line-with-expectations-but-stock-drops-151/technicalsSecondary
- https://www.tradingkey.com/news/market-movers/262268052-market-movers-shop-20261103technicalsSecondary
Caveats
Time sensitivity: every price, multiple, and technical reading here is a November 3, 2026 snapshot taken on the day of an 8.7% earnings gap-down, which is the single worst day on which to treat such figures as stable [2][17]. Price itself is unsettled across sources — the official close is cited at both $142.57 and $142.69, intraday declines ranged from roughly -7.6% to -15.3%, and other trackers showed $147.88 with market caps spanning $204B to $253B against the $183.4B-$183.6B figures used — so only the closing print should be treated as firm, and all percentage distances from moving averages, highs, and lows are arithmetic derived from it rather than published values [2][12][14][17][20][24]. Source quality is uneven by claim type. The Q3 operating figures — revenue, GMV, segment revenue, MRR, gross profit, operating income, FCF, GAAP and non-GAAP net income and EPS, the $117M/$122M investment loss, the $68M tax recovery, and every guidance element — come from the primary Exhibit 99.1 8-K press release and Shopify's own newsroom, and are high confidence [1][3][4][5][9][10][15][16]. Everything valuation-, consensus-, and technical-related is secondary aggregator data (stockanalysis.com, MarketBeat, Benzinga, TipRanks, Investing.com, GuruFocus, valueinvesting.io) and is medium confidence [7][8][11][14][18][19][20][21][22][23][25]. EV/EBITDA is deliberately a range (69.70x, 83.85x, 95.63x) because sources differ on date and EBITDA definition, not because the business changed [7][8]. The ~90.8x five-year median trailing P/E is the weakest single link — it comes from secondary commentary and conflicts in direction with the ~50x five-year average EV/EBITDA benchmark, so 'above' versus 'below' its own history depends on which multiple and which source you use [8][19]. The analyst consensus is the most perishable item: the $176-$178 averages and nearly all firm-level targets were set before the November 3 print, analyst counts differ across trackers (32, 49, 54, 55) with differing lag windows, and the Goldman ($168) and Wells Fargo ($191) marks date from February 2026 — so the 'roughly 24% upside' figure describes a pre-earnings consensus against a post-earnings price and may reset in either direction [11][18][21][22]. Peer comparisons are directional only: Amazon's scale and negative FCF, MercadoLibre's first-party retail and logistics mix, and Commerce.com's ~2% growth outlook each make the multiple gap non-like-for-like, and Shopify's take-rate-on-GMV model books far less gross revenue per dollar of commerce, which distorts price-to-sales specifically [8][19][20]. Not covered: no Q3 2026 10-Q detail beyond the press release, no cohort or merchant-retention data, no take-rate decomposition explaining the subscription-versus-merchant-solutions divergence, no competitive or market-share analysis, no earnings-call management commentary beyond the cited transcript headline, no macro consumer-spending or holiday-season demand data ahead of the guided Q4, no insider or institutional ownership flows, no detail on the AI/agentic-commerce initiatives cited as the spending driver, and no analysis of the TSX listing beyond one pre-earnings C$223 support reference [3][5][10][23]. The composition of the equity-investment portfolio producing the $122M after-tax loss is not disclosed in the cited material, so its future volatility cannot be sized — only noted as non-operating and directionally non-recurring [16]. This report presents evidence only and contains no buy, sell, or hold recommendation; the valuation, growth, and momentum trade-offs described are for the reader to weigh.
This report is for informational purposes only and is not investment advice. No buy / sell / hold recommendation is made or implied.